Thanksgiving Ordering

Now taking orders for Thanksgiving!

We will be open the following days for Thanksgiving

  • Tuesday, November 24th  – 5:00 am to 5:00 pm
  • Wednesday, November 25th – 5:00 am to 5:00pm
Pick-ups available 5:00am to 4:15 pm each day.

The bakery will be closed on Thanksgiving, Thursday, Nov. 26th thru Monday, Nov. 30th.

After the 18th, orders will be not accepted. Tues. Nov. 24th and Wed. Nov. 25th we will have items available for walk ins only on a first come, first serve basis.

**We will stop taking orders early if we hit our capacity, please order earlier vs. later.

Please call 612-789-2827 between 930am and 230pm, email sarahjanesbakery@gmail.com or stop by the store to place your order.

When emailing in orders please, please, please include the following:

  • Date of pick up
  • Requested one hour time window – Pick ups are between 5 am and 4pm. Please select one hour window in even hours, (ex. 7am-8am or 9am-10am), if it is full we will let you know what is available.
  • Items you would like
  • First and Last name for the order
  • Phone Number
We will confirm all emailed orders once we have time to respond! Typically with in 48 hours. No need to request a confirmation.
We are located at 2853 Johnson St NE. MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55418
Pies

The pies listed below are the ONLY flavors available for pick up the week of Thanksgiving (Tues. Nov. 24th or Wed. Nov. 25th) Unfortunately, not all of our pie flavors will be available. We have a maximum capacity for each flavor available, once the maximum has been reached, the flavor will be crossed off and no longer available.

All pies are 9 inches, approximately 8 servings. (No need to request 9 inch pie, we only have one size)

$16.25

  • Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal Fall Flavor)

$19.25

  • Classic Apple Pie
  • Dutch Apple Pie SOLD OUT

$20.25

  • Harvest Apple Pie (apple filling with cranberries, raisins and pecans topped with brown sugar crumble)
  • Maine Wild Blueberry Pie
  • Rhubarb Custard Pie
  • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

$21.25

  • Key Lime Pie
  • Michigan Sour Cherry Pie
  • Tripleberry Pie (Blueberries, Blackberries and Raspberries)

$22.25

  • French Silk Pie
  • Pecan Pie

Desserts (ALL BARS AND COOKIES ARE PRICED AND SOLD INDIVIDUALLY)

  • Frosted Turkey Sugar Cookies – $2.45 per cookie (add someone’s name for additional .25)
  • Apple Pie Squares – $3.10
  • Caramel Apple Cheesecake Bars – $3.10
  • Pumpkin Bars – $2.10
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake Bars – $3.10
  • Pecan Pie Bar w. Brown Butter Shortbread Crust – $3.10

Bread

  • Dinner Rolls (12 pack of slider buns)
    • White – $4.75
    • Cranberry Wild Rice – $5.25

Breakfast Items

  • Pumpkin Spice Latte Roll – $3.10
  • Connie the Turkey Coffeecake approx. 18 people  $33.00 (limited availability)

CONNIE IS SOLD OUT! NO LONER AVAILABLE FOR PRE-ORDERING!

Almond Coffeecake body with cherry, blueberry, apple and pumpkin “feathers” (no flavor customizations)

Coffeecakes
Almond Coffee Cake – $10.75
Almond Paste Coffee Cake – $10.75
Butter Pecan Coffee Cake – $10.75
Cardamom Coffee Cake – $12.75
Cardamom Almond Coffee Cake – $12.75
Assorted Fruit Coffee Cakes – $10.75
Flavor Choices:( Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Raspberry, Strawberry, Rhubarb, Lemon)
Cream Cheese and Fruit Coffee Cake – $11.50(Pick one fruit from above list)
Honey Nut Coffee Cake – $10.75
Poppyseed Coffee Cake – $11.75
Cinnamon Raisin Coffee Cake – $10.75
Cinnamon Nut Coffee Cake – $10.75