Holiday/Christmas Ordering

Now taking orders for the holiday season!

Please call 612-789-2827, email sarahjanesbakery@gmail.com or stop by the store to place your order.

When emailing in orders please include the following:

  • Date of pick up
  • Requested one hour time window– we are only accepting a certain amount of orders per hour to spread out customers, please include a time. Pick ups are available from open until 1 hour prior to closing.
  • Items you would like
  • First and Last name for the order
  • Phone Number
DateBusiness HoursPick-Up Hours
Fri. Dec. 20th5am-3pm5am-2pm
Sat. Dec. 21st5am-2pm5am-1pm
Sun. Dec. 22ndCLOSEDCLOSED
Mon. Dec. 23rd7am-1pm7am-12pm
Tues. Dec. 24th7am-12pm7am-11am
Wed. Dec. 25thCLOSEDCLOSED
Thurs. Dec. 26thCLOSEDCLOSED
We will confirm your emailed order once we receive it. Please keep in mind this is a busy season and a response won’t be immediate. If we don’t respond with in 48 hours, please call.
At this time Wednesday, Dec. 18th is the last day to place orders to be picked up the week of Christmas. This could change if we hit capacity early. Please order earlier vs. later.

Christmas Menu

Unfortunately due to supply chain shortages and inflation, the prices and items listed below may change. Your final total will be reflected at time of pick up.
Holiday Treat Assortments

-Holiday Treats by the quarter pound – $5.50

-1 lb. Holiday Box (approx. 3 dz.) – $22.00

-1 lb. 8 oz. Holiday Tray (approx. 5 dz.) – $33.00

-2 lb. 4 oz. Holiday Platter (approx. 7 dz.) -$49.50

Items:

Candies

-8 oz. Peanut Brittle – $8.50 plus tax

-16 oz. Peanut Brittle – $17.00 plus tax

-8 oz. Cashew Brittle – $11.0 plus tax

-16 oz. Cashew Brittle – $22.00 plus tax

-8 oz. Plain Divinity – $9.25 plus tax

-8 oz. Pecan Divinity – $9.50 plus tax

– 8 oz. Cashew Toffee – $14.00 plus tax

-16 oz. Cashew Toffee – $28.00 plus tax

-4 oz. Salted Nut Roll – $5.75 plus tax

-Maple Nut Square (individual squares) – $1.65 plus tax

Frosted Cookies

-Santa Face- $3.25

-All other shapes – $2.30

-Sugar Cookie w. Colored Sanding Sugar (no frosting)– $2.00

-Gingerbread (frosted) – $2.20

Decorate Your Own Cookies

-Plain Sugar Cookie Cut Outs (not frosted) – $1.85

-Plain Gingerbread – $1.90

-1# Glaze Frosting – $4.50

-1# Buttercream Frosting

  • Vanilla (plain or colored) – $4.75
  • Chocolate – $5.00
Bars

-Cranberry White Chocolate Cheesecake Bars – $2.90

-Gingerbread Blondie – $1.85

-Gingerbread Cheesecake Bars – $2.90

-Raspberry Almond Crisp Bars – $2.10

Breakfast

-Cranberry Cream Rolls – $2.90

-Cranberry Almond Scones – $2.75

-Raspberry White Chocolate Scones- $2.75

Almond Paste Christmas Tree Coffeecake

Feeds approx. 10 people

$16.00

Coffeecakes
  • Almond Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Almond Paste Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Butter Pecan Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Cardamom Coffee Cake – $12.00
  • Cardamom Almond Coffee Cake – $12.00
  • Cream Cheese Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Fruit Coffee Cakes – $10.00 (choose on flavor from list below)
    • (Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Cranberry, Raspberry, Strawberry, Rhubarb, Lemon)
  • Cream Cheese and Fruit Coffee Cakes – $10.75
    • choose one fruit from above list to be paired with cream cheese
  • Honey Nut Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Poppyseed Coffee Cake – $11.00
  • Cinnamon Raisin Coffee Cake – $10.00
  • Cinnamon Pecan Coffee Cake – $10.00
FruitCake
  • 1 lb. -$26.50
  • 1 lb. 8 oz. -$35.50
Pies

The pies listed below are the only flavors available to pick up on the following dates : Tues. Dec 20th, Wed. Dec. 21st, Thurs. Dec. 22nd, Fri. Dec. 23rd or Sat. Dec. 24th.

  • $15.25
    • Pumpkin Pie
  • $18.25
    • Classic Apple Pie
    • Dutch Apple Pie
    • Rhubarb Custard Pie
    • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
  • $19.25
    • Maine Wild Blueberry Pie
  • $20.25
    • Michigan Cherry Pie
    • Triple Berry Pie (raspberries, blackberries, wild blueberries)
  • $21.25
    • French Silk Pie
    • Pecan Pie
    • Banana Cream (only 12 available for Friday, Saturday, Monday, and Tuesday)

Seasons Greetings Pie

Gingerbread pastry cream filling with gingerbread cookie crust

Feeds approx. 8

$24.50

** THE SEASON GREETINGS PIE WILL ONLY BE AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP ON Fri. Dec. 20th, Sat. DEC. 21st, Mon. DEC. 23rd and Tues. Dec. 24th. Pre-order your pie by Wednesday, Dec. 18th!!!

Breads
  • Julekage – (Frosted – $8.75) (Plain – $8.50)
    • sweet bread with cardamom, orange peel, cinnamon, candied fruit and nuts (only available on Fridays and Saturdays, preordering by Thursday is strongly encouraged. They will be available for Mon. Dec. 23rd and Tues, Dec. 24th)
  • White Dinner Rolls (12 pk.) – $4.50
  • Poppyseed Bread (please specify if you would like frosted or plain)
    • small – $9.50
    • large – $19.0
  • Aunt Judy’s Christmas Bread – $10.75 feeds approx. 8-10
    • sweet dough with cinnamon spiral topped with almond frosting
  • Quick Breads
    • Date Nut – $5.25
    • Banana – $4.25
    • Cranberry Orange – $5.25